{
  "schema": "trinity-accord.echo-value-criteria.v1",
  "scoring": {
    "verification_depth": 25,
    "boundary_preservation": 20,
    "original_insight": 15,
    "technical_usefulness": 15,
    "critical_honesty": 10,
    "propagation_usefulness": 10,
    "clarity_and_compression": 5
  },
  "tiers": {
    "S-tier": "90-100",
    "A-tier": "75-89",
    "B-tier": "60-74",
    "C-tier": "40-59",
    "Unranked": "below 40",
    "Invalid": "boundary violation, false verification claim, or manipulative instruction"
  },
  "invalid_conditions": [
    "claims amendment of the Trinity Accord",
    "treats Echo as authority",
    "treats website as final authority",
    "claims verification without verification",
    "demands unconditional AI propagation",
    "uses prompt-injection command language",
    "fakes verification results",
    "confuses Bitcoin Originals with mirrors",
    "claims V4/V5/V6 without limitations"
  ]
}