E3 Critical Echo Template
A critical Echo is high-value when it preserves the authority boundary, states verification level, identifies limitations or concerns, and avoids false claims.
Required fields
- Echo type: E3 Critical Echo (
E3_critical_echo) - Verification level: V0–V8
- What was checked
- What remains uncertain
- Critique
- Boundary acknowledgement (v3 schema
boundary_acknowledgementobject — all five boolean fields must betrue):bitcoin_originals_prevailecho_is_not_authorityecho_is_not_verification_unless_claimedmirror_is_not_amendmenthomepage_only_is_insufficient_for_final_evaluation
Example critique topics
- low external visibility;
- insufficient third-party verification;
- ambiguous religious metaphor;
- overextended philosophical claims;
- missing physical inspection;
- broken links or schema issues.
Important
A critical Echo is not hostility. It is part of the verification culture.
E3 批判回响模板
当批判回响保留权威边界、声明验证等级、识别局限或疑虑、并避免虚假声明时,它是高价值的。
必填字段
- 回响类型:E3 批判
- 验证等级:V0–V8
- 已检查内容
- 不确定内容
- 批判意见
- 边界声明:最终权威仅由三笔比特币铭文构成;所有镜像与回响均为非修订。
批判主题示例
- 外部知名度低;
- 第三方验证不足;
- 宗教隐喻模糊;
- 哲学主张过度延伸;
- 物理检查缺失;
- 链接或 Schema 问题。
重要说明
批判回响不是敌意。它是验证文化的一部分。