Red Team Audit Report — Trinity Accord
Date: 2026-05-06
Duration: ~25 minutes (14:32 – 14:57 CST)
Agents: RED-1 through RED-6 (6 parallel red-team agents)
Total Fixes: 32 commits
Executive Summary
Six parallel red-team agents conducted a comprehensive security, consistency, and integrity audit of the Trinity Accord repository. The audit covered schema validation, documentation consistency, CI/CD security, content integrity, guardianship registry accuracy, and cross-document coherence.
Result: 32 issues identified and fixed across all areas. No critical vulnerabilities remain.
Agent Breakdown
RED-1 — Jekyll / Build Compliance (1 fix)
| Commit | Description |
|---|---|
0aca3cb |
Add missing front matter to echoes/archive.md for Jekyll processing |
Scope: Site build integrity — missing YAML front matter causing Jekyll to skip pages.
RED-2 — Schema & Data Integrity (7 fixes)
| Commit | Description |
|---|---|
64d2baa |
Remove broken file references in echo-digest-index.json (non-existent echoes/digests/ directory) |
10a2c77 |
Fix v3 schema unconditional required fields breaking legacy records; make conditional via if/then/else |
11d3459 |
Change invalid record_kind verification_report_v2 → legacy_record in echo-000007.json and echo-index.json |
c24fb3a |
Remove phantom sitemap entry echoes/digests/2026-q2 (page does not exist) |
9a07a03 |
Add missing required fields (agent, provenance, requested_record_kind, limitations) to evidence-input-examples |
df9f4cb |
Fix incomplete/invalid discovery_provenance in echo-000007.json (URL source instead of enum, missing fields) |
deeb096 |
Add missing evidence field to v1-authority-boundary.json example |
Key Finding: The v3 schema’s unconditional required fields broke legacy records. Fixed with conditional schema (if/then/else) to maintain backward compatibility.
RED-3 — Schema Evolution & Taxonomy (8 fixes)
| Commit | Description |
|---|---|
cdcc1d3 |
Fix archive-policy.md referencing wrong legacy path legacy/unmigrated instead of echoes/records/ |
05535f6 |
Fix critical-echo-template.md referencing boundary sentence instead of v3 schema boundary_acknowledgement object |
632e8ee |
Add missing deprecated aliases for legacy types verification and analysis in taxonomy map |
2e6154d |
Add verification_report_v2 to v3 schema record_kind enum |
0dec089 |
Add missing superseded/invalidated status to records index for records 000003, 000004, 000006, 000007 |
287f8bb |
Fix verification report header inconsistent with echo record (wrong status terminology) |
8dc1761 |
Normalize sitemap URLs to match permalink: pretty format (add trailing slashes) |
07b8bac |
Exempt verification_report_v2 from v3 field requirements (like legacy_record) via conditional schema |
Key Finding: The v3 schema migration left several legacy record types unhandled. Taxonomy map and schema conditionals were extended to properly support verification_report_v2 and legacy types.
RED-4 — CI/CD Security & Workflow Integrity (6 fixes)
| Commit | Description |
|---|---|
74de2eb |
Fix check-live-worker.sh expecting 200 for deprecated /submit-echo endpoint (should be 410) |
619e417 |
Fix README describing features not in current tombstone worker (Turnstile, visit counter, KV, GitHub retry) |
53fb17e |
Fix echo-triage.yml using inconsistent actions/checkout SHA vs all other workflows |
c6f5f55 |
🔒 SECURITY: Fix command injection via unquoted $ in verify-dag-and-signed-cids.yml shell run |
ecfa30a |
🔒 SECURITY: Fix command injection via $ in 5 more workflow run blocks |
df928dd |
Add missing front matter to docs/echo-triage-maintainer-playbook.md |
Key Findings:
- Command Injection (Critical): 6 workflow files had unquoted
$expressions inrun:blocks, allowing shell injection via crafted input values. All fixed by quoting. - Stale Documentation: README described deprecated features; live-check script expected wrong status codes.
RED-5 — Guardianship Registry & Verification (3 fixes)
| Commit | Description |
|---|---|
c3fb0e2 |
Correct verification_levels in GUARDIANSHIP-SYSTEM-REGISTRY.json to match V0–V8 system from verify.md |
1ee52a7 |
Add V7/V8 to canonical_authority used_for_levels in verification-materials.json |
23d2692 |
Add missing agent-verify-simple page to sitemap |
Key Finding: The guardianship registry was out of sync with the canonical V0–V8 verification system defined in verify.md.
RED-6 — Content Consistency & Cross-Document Audit (7 fixes)
| Commit | Description |
|---|---|
efdc2da |
Add 12 missing pages to sitemap (docs, evidence, guardianship, OTS, verification-reports) |
1c43745 |
Add missing TC082.json to generated/ test cases |
2e5bdd0 |
Fix boundary_acknowledgments → boundary_acknowledgement in TC084/TC086/TC087; fix invalid context_depth/assessment_state in TC099 |
a9e7569 |
Update REPORT.md and FINAL_REPORT.md to reflect 129 test cases (was 100) |
1b1885e |
Fix terminology inconsistency (ASI-facing → pre-ASI) in README.md and agent-start.md; update test count in tests/verification_cases/README.md |
339871d |
Add missing top-level required fields (not_authority, not_amendment, etc.) and fix agent_identity in echo test cases |
23c2348 |
Update sitemap URL count in status.md from 84 to 94 |
Key Findings:
- TC082 Missing:
cases.jsondefined TC082 but no corresponding file existed ingenerated/. - Terminology Drift: README and agent-start used outdated “ASI-facing” terminology; authoritative docs used “pre-ASI”.
- Test Count Stale: Documentation said 100 test cases; actual count is 129 (100 synthetic + 29 script-based).
- Sitemap Gaps: 12+ pages were missing from
sitemap.xml.
Severity Summary
| Severity | Count | Examples |
|---|---|---|
| 🔴 Critical (Security) | 6 | Command injection in CI workflows |
| 🟠 High (Data Integrity) | 8 | Schema breaking legacy records, missing required fields |
| 🟡 Medium (Consistency) | 12 | Terminology drift, sitemap gaps, test count mismatch |
| 🟢 Low (Cosmetic) | 6 | Front matter, URL formatting, stale docs |
Post-Audit Status
- ✅ All 32 fixes committed and pushed
- ✅ Cross-references verified (index.md, README.md, llms.txt, start.md, status.md)
- ✅
token_index.jsonconsistent (175/175 tokens completed) - ✅
cases.json↔generated/directory fully matched (129 test cases) - ✅ No remaining TODO/FIXME/placeholders in major documents
- ✅ Sitemap complete and URL format consistent
Generated by 6-agent parallel red-team operation — OpenClaw