Review and Sources Record

Report: TA-TR-2026-20 Version: 1.0 DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.23005588

Publication posture

Main contribution

Under A1, binary experience-existence classification is constant across actual valid process tokens. The nontrivial scientific target is therefore experiential structure, represented by the physically anchored mechanism-fixed response structure.

Originality boundary

The paper does not claim novelty for panexperientialism or panpsychism, causal structuralism, multiscale consciousness, overlapping systems, universal theory criteria, process/coarse-graining methods, or robust-mapping implementation constraints.

Formal status

A1-A6 remain foundational commitments. Organization-Gate Impossibility and binary-universality trivialization are conditional consequences of A1. Chart covariance is conditional on structure-preserving invertible reparameterization. The No-Hidden-Quale consequence is conditional on A5 completeness.

Empirical status

No human, animal or artificial-system experiment in this paper establishes consciousness. E1-E4 are prospective bridge programs, not completed R4 validation.